In 2025, James Gunn delivered a new Superman movie that was witty and thrilling, a film I very much enjoyed. So did a lot of other people with the movie racking up a very strong box office and nearly unanimous positive reviews.
Feeling very hopeful about the future of the DC cinematic universe under James Gunn, I was anxious to see what would come next.
Which brings us to today's movie post.
It... Movie Time!
Earlier this summer, Supergirl was released and failed to replicate even a portion of the success of the 2025 Superman.
It certainly did not bring me into the theater to see it.
A week or so back, Supergirl turned up on HBO Max and I thought I would give this movie a try from the comfort of my own Fortress of Ineptitude home.
I rather liked the movie but I am clearly see why it went bust in theaters.
If what you know of Supergirl is the perfectly composed Melissa Benoist from the CW series who was as likely to solve a problem with a super speech of super positivity than to super punch it, well....
As we caught a glimpse of at the end of the 2025 Superman film, Zara Zor-El is a frequently inebriated party girl who likes to pub crawl on worlds with a red sun.
Super powers that include invulnerability preclude getting drunk.
We pick up with Kara with her dog Krypto "celebrating" her 23rd birthday on the planet Holzherr. I put that in quotes because for all the partying and the drinking, Kara does not appear to be having much fun.
Unlike Kal-El who was rocketed off Krypton when he was infant, Kara grew up with her Kryptonian parents, living her life in a Kryptonian culture. She remembers all of that before they all died.
Kara's legacy with Krypton is a burden her cousin can not understand.
While drowning her pain in an alien bar, Kara meets Ruthye Marye Knoll. Armed with her father's sword, Ruthye is on a quest of vengeance against Krem, a alien thug who slaughtered her parents and her brother.
Krem and his gang of Brigands are ruthless, malicious punks who traffic in stolen weapons, wealth and women.
Or more accurately, young girls to serve as breeding stock for the all male Brigands.
While stealing Kara's ship, Krem shoots Krypto with a poison dart, a poison that will take the dog's life within 72 hours if Kara cannot recover the antidode.
Going all John Wick, Kara resolves go after Krem.
Ruthye resolves to accompany Kara.
Kara say no.
Ruthye goes with her anyway.
What follows is a gauntet of weird aliens, dark and dreadful cities and unforgiving alien landscapes as Kara and Ruthye encounter various obstacles on their quest.
Things do get a bit easier once Kara hits a yellow sun system and powers up for some epic ass kicking.
Along the way, Lobo shows up for... reasons.
Jason Mamoa's Lobo does bring a welcome jolt of comics accurate chaotic energy to the proceedings but to be honest, he feels extraneous.
Lobo feels like a studio note that said we need some reason for men to see a movie about Supergirl.
Speaking of Supergirl, Kara does suit up in the big red S super suit for the movie's final act for high flying cape flapping action.
My assessment is I made the right call in not seeing Supergirl in the theater. The movie feels sort of small.
Watching it from the comfort of home, this smallness seems less of a problem. The main thing of interest to me in this film has less to do with any potential spectacle and more on the relationship between Kara and Ruthye.
Which really doesn't resonate as strongly as it should as the film rushes past various plot points to a proscribed conclusion.
I almost thing that Supergirl would have benefit from being a TV series in the mode of Lanterns with a slow burn story arc that would've provided more chances for depth and nuance in the Kara and Ruthye dynamic and more power to Kara's growth from where we find her to where she winds up.
Kudos to cameos from David Corenswet as Superman who still such a hopeless dork.
When Supergirl was released back in June, reviews about the movie as a whole were most decidedly mixed, leaning towards negative. But one consistent point that was made across all those reviews is that Milly Aycock is awesome as Kara.
An assessment I agree with. Her Kara is not something we're used to seeing in the Superman mythos, a character floundering with her trauma, her grief and loss. Her attempts to dull her pain with partying and drinking could feel like whiny self indulgence but this is a young woman who has earned this and we feel that pain.
But even with all that she's going through, Kara still can't stop her self from trying to help when someone else is in pain, like Ruthye.
Ultimately, I see why Supergirl didn't play well on the big screen there is enough good here to make me think this movie deserves a better reception that being known as the pariah of the DC Cinematic Universe.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Tomorrow, Star Trekking brings us to the season 4 finale of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds.



